From: Knobdoodle on

"Peter Wyzl" <wyzelli(a)yahoo.com> wrote:
> Since when did Darren Lockyer (good as he is) get to be 'best footballer
> in the world'?
>
Who's better?
Sure there's plenty of talented up-and-comers like Jonathon Thurston and
Greg Inglis and plenty of almost were's like Sonny Bill Williams, Anthony
Minicello and Hazem El Mazri and even a few bright sparks like Andrew Johns
and Danny Buderous and but who else has achieved as much as Locky during his
decade-plus career?
Fark; he's practically carried the Maroon State-Of-Origin effort on his back
for the last 10 years!!
--
Clem
(Or is this an "NRL isn't football" post?)


From: Knobdoodle on

"bikerbetty" <bikerbetty(a)gmail.com> wrote:
> Eeeek, as I said.... is any of this Cats & pies and so on English.....?
> ;-)
>
You're right; cats are much better in stir-fry!
--
Clem


From: Peter Wyzl on
"Knobdoodle" <knobdoodle(a)hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:%p0Si.1793$CN4.841(a)news-server.bigpond.net.au...
>
> "Peter Wyzl" <wyzelli(a)yahoo.com> wrote:
>> Since when did Darren Lockyer (good as he is) get to be 'best footballer
>> in the world'?
>>
> Who's better?
> Sure there's plenty of talented up-and-comers like Jonathon Thurston and
> Greg Inglis and plenty of almost were's like Sonny Bill Williams, Anthony
> Minicello and Hazem El Mazri and even a few bright sparks like Andrew
> Johns and Danny Buderous and but who else has achieved as much as Locky
> during his decade-plus career?
> Fark; he's practically carried the Maroon State-Of-Origin effort on his
> back for the last 10 years!!


"A few bright sparks like Andrew Johns......"

Therein ends the conversation.

P

From: Knobdoodle on

"Peter Wyzl" <wyzelli(a)yahoo.com> wrote:
> "A few bright sparks like Andrew Johns......"
>
> Therein ends the conversation.
>
[shrug]
Brilliant but inconsistent!
What's he starred in, two State of Origin series and one finals series?
Not much to show for such a long career ....
--
Clem


From: Peter Wyzl on
"Knobdoodle" <knobdoodle(a)hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:WoaSi.1970$CN4.707(a)news-server.bigpond.net.au...
>
> "Peter Wyzl" <wyzelli(a)yahoo.com> wrote:
>> "A few bright sparks like Andrew Johns......"
>>
>> Therein ends the conversation.
>>
> [shrug]
> Brilliant but inconsistent!
> What's he starred in, two State of Origin series and one finals series?
> Not much to show for such a long career ....


I'll put it down to the meds giving you maroon vision...

Stats:
(I won't bother with finals, because arguably that says more about the team,
than individual brilliance, there being many players who have not played in
finals who have represented Australia in the same year.)

First grade games :
AJ 249 (ret) DL 275 (still going)
Points :
AJ 2176 DL 1134
Origin
AJ 23 games 96 points, DL 27 games 73 points
Australia
AJ 21 Games DL 36 games

DL has certainly played more and has been more consistent at a very high
level (both have suffered from injuries), but look at the scoring.

Now, I'm not suggesting that Darren is not a brilliant player, and I think
he is certainly one of the best of all time, but I think to call him 'The'
best of all time sadly misses the value of that player in the team.

Joey holds the NRL record for most points in career, most points in a
season, most goals in a season, most field goals in a season, most tries in
a match (shared), most goals in a match, most points in a match, plus club
records of most appearances, most goals and most field goals.

Both Joey and Darren are the only players to have won the golden boot more
than once, (hopefully DL can do it again), but Joey alone has won the 'Dally
M' 3 times.

DL is the second highest kangaroos try scorer.

So, while DL is a brilliant player, and certainly _one of_ the best, points
per game nobody comes remotely close to Joey (AJ over 8 points per game and
DL just over 4 lifetime average).

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrew_Johns
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Darren_Lockyer

Enjoy.

P